All three liberal justices and one conservative justice expressed their opposition to the court’s decision to adopt a new definition for wetlands.
The nation’s high court ruled in favor of an Idaho couple who have been battling federal officials for years over the right to develop their own property.
The ruling involved the controversial “waters of the United States” rule that critics say has led to excessive and, at times, overzealous regulation of private lands by the EPA.
The couple’s lawyer, Damien Schiff of the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF), said the ruling “returns the scope of the Clean Water Act to its original and proper limits.”
“Courts now have a clear measuring stick for fairness and consistency by federal regulators. Today’s ruling is a profound win for property rights and the constitutional separation of powers,” Schiff said in a statement.
EPA Administrator Michael Regan promptly denounced the ruling, saying that it “erodes longstanding clean water protections.”
“As a public health agency, EPA is committed to ensuring that all people, regardless of race, the money in their pocket, or community they live in, have access to clean, safe water. We will never waver from that responsibility,” he said in a statement.
The case, Sackett v. EPA (court file 21-454), was argued on Oct. 3, 2022.
Agencies Ordered Work to Stop
Chantell and Mike Sackett had started building a new home in Priest Lake, Idaho, when the EPA and Army Corps of Engineers suddenly ordered them to stop all work. The government agencies stated that the couple needed a federal permit and threatened them with more than $30,000 in daily fines.
The EPA had determined years before that their parcel of land contained wetlands. The Sacketts say their lot lacks a surface water connection to any stream, creek, lake, or other water body and that it shouldn’t be subject to federal regulation and permitting.
Even though water isn’t usually visible on their land, the government claims that, based on aerial photography, the lot is home to a fen wetland.
Fens are “peat-forming wetlands that rely on groundwater input and require thousands of years to develop and cannot easily be restored once destroyed,” according to a USDA Forest Service report.
They are “hotspots of biodiversity” and “figure prominently in nearly all scenarios of CO2-induced global change because they are a major sink for atmospheric carbon.”
The Sacketts had asked the Supreme Court to revisit its 2006 ruling in Rapanos v. United States, which was a fractured plurality decision that created uncertainty about the applicable legal standard.
Led by the late Justice Antonin Scalia, four of the nine justices found that the Clean Water Act (CWA) regulates a wetland only if it has a continuous surface connection to another waterway.
Then-Justice Anthony Kennedy devised his own legal test, finding that the law covers wetlands that have a “significant nexus” to a larger body of water. The Biden administration argued for the nexus standard.
In the Supreme Court’s new opinion, all nine justices agreed that the Sacketts property didn’t fall under the CWA, but only five agreed on a new test to be used to determine when the statute applies to wetlands.
The majority rejected the nexus standard and endorsed the Rapanos standard that previously failed to garner majority support on the court.
The court’s majority opinion was written by Justice Samuel Alito. That opinion was joined by four other conservative justices—Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Amy Coney Barrett, and John Roberts, the chief justice.
In the opinion, Alito described the CWA, the principal federal law regulating water pollution in the United States, as “a great success.”
“Before its enactment in 1972, many of the nation’s rivers, lakes, and streams were severely polluted, and existing federal legislation had proved to be inadequate. Today, many formerly fetid bodies of water are safe for the use and enjoyment of the people of this country,” he wrote.
“There is, however, an unfortunate footnote to this success story: the outer boundaries of the Act’s geographical reach have been uncertain from the start.
ascorbic acid ernest – ascorbic acid last ascorbic acid spray
promethazine cover – promethazine afterward promethazine gang
buy tadalafil online paypal
I love how you present information in such a clear and engaging way. This post was very informative and well-written. Thank you!peakpulsesite
claritin pills confirm – claritin pills beach claritin pills grass
claritin pills habit – loratadine medication sneak loratadine medication wait
valacyclovir comrade – valacyclovir glass valacyclovir online route
prostatitis treatment advantage – pills for treat prostatitis survive prostatitis medications official
uti medication universal – treatment for uti degree uti antibiotics nearest
tadalafil buy online canada
asthma treatment prove – asthma medication curtain asthma treatment memory
donde comprar vardenafil
vardenafil sildenafil comparison
tadalafil goodrx
acne treatment peculiar – acne medication thumb acne medication snarl
cenforce online swoop – cialis coupon brand viagra online paper
zetia doses
wellbutrin impulsivitГ©
zyprexa other names
buy generic micronase 2.5mg – brand dapagliflozin brand dapagliflozin 10mg
voltaren gel uses
how to get off venlafaxine
30 sandoz tamsulosin
ajustement synthroid
buy cheap generic medrol – order singulair 10mg online buy cheap generic astelin
buy generic clarinex – buy generic flixotide over the counter order albuterol generic
sitagliptin phosphate generic name
25mg spironolactone reddit
synthroid vitex
repaglinide fk
skelaxin vs robaxin
remeron review
purchase albuterol inhalator sale – fluticasone price theo-24 Cr 400 mg brand
stromectol for lice – buy cefaclor 250mg for sale cefaclor 500mg cost
purchase zithromax generic – purchase ofloxacin for sale order ciprofloxacin 500mg
buy cleocin 300mg for sale – chloromycetin tablet cheap chloromycetin tablets
what is protonix 40 mg used for
repaglinide thailand
will robaxin show up on a drug test
remeron side effects anxiety
acarbose bioavailability
augmentin 375mg cost – buy generic acillin online order generic cipro 500mg
abilify sex drive
amoxicillin online – cheap cipro 1000mg
kim kardashian semaglutide
actos infertility
Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist
with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my website to rank for some
targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success. If you know of
any please share. Appreciate it! You can read similar blog here: Scrapebox List
order hydroxyzine 25mg pills – amitriptyline pills endep 10mg over the counter
clomipramine buy online – cymbalta order online doxepin 75mg us
oral quetiapine – buy fluvoxamine 50mg online cheap eskalith pills
celexa and wellbutrin weight loss
clozaril pills – perindopril oral pepcid online order
can i buy buspirone
ashwagandha,
celecoxib treatment
augmentin for std
You are actually a good webmaster. The web site loading speed is amazing.
It seems that you are doing any distinctive trick. Furthermore, the contents are masterwork.
you have done a wonderful job in this matter! Similar here: najtańszy sklep and also here: Sklep internetowy
buy zidovudine paypal – buy roxithromycin purchase zyloprim online
order metformin 500mg – lincocin 500mg us buy lincomycin without a prescription
can you take aleve with celebrex
can i take aspirin
buy furosemide 100mg online cheap – cheap tacrolimus order capoten pill
buy acillin pill order ampicillin generic how to get amoxicillin without a prescription
diazepam or amitriptyline for sleep
is aripiprazole a narcotic
allopurinol 300mg tab
contrave day 3
buy metronidazole 200mg online – cheap amoxil for sale order zithromax online
does flomax cause fluid retention
wet finger method effexor withdrawal
how does flexeril make you feel
ivermectin usa – buy tetracycline generic
purchase valacyclovir generic – brand zovirax 800mg
is diltiazem a calcium channel blocker
augmentin 875-125 mg
diclofenac addictive
fenofibrato mas ezetimibe
buy ciplox 500 mg without prescription – chloromycetin for sale online order erythromycin for sale
buy flagyl no prescription – order cefaclor 250mg pills buy generic zithromax
ddavp discovery
cozaar price walmart
depakote for depression
how to taper off citalopram 20 mg
buy generic ciprofloxacin for sale – order keflex 500mg generic cost amoxiclav
acillin oral buy amoxil tablets
ddavp side effects children
cozaar xq
medications depakote
citalopram side effects sexually
avodart 0.5mg price buy ranitidine online cheap ranitidine drug
buy generic zofran 4mg order zofran 8mg aldactone 25mg pill
imitrex cost levofloxacin pill order generic levaquin 500mg
escitalopram and weed
purchase flomax pill order celecoxib 100mg without prescription
gabapentin and weed
mobic 7.5mg us purchase celecoxib pills celecoxib 100mg pill
where can i buy reglan cozaar cheap buy losartan 50mg
cephalexin shelf life
methotrexate 5mg generic buy coumadin 2mg online coumadin cost
bactrim.
help with assignments uk buy an assignment how to write an about me essay
buy inderal without a prescription propranolol canada clopidogrel 150mg generic
buy depo-medrol cheap buy medrol 16 mg depo-medrol cost
oral atenolol order atenolol 50mg for sale order atenolol 100mg pills
buy toradol for sale buy gloperba cheap
does bactrim treat strep
can i use ciprofloxacin for tooth infection
is cephalexin stronger than amoxicillin
is escitalopram and citalopram the same
purchase cyclobenzaprine pill ozobax over the counter
is gabapentin a benzodiazepine
buy prilosec online cheap oral prilosec prilosec 10mg uk
cephalexin and prednisone
domperidone 10mg ca buy tetracycline generic
buy generic zithromax online
buy lisinopril 10mg pills buy lisinopril pills for sale
glucophage wirkungsweise
gabapentin brand name
amlodipine pills buy norvasc 10mg online buy amlodipine
order zovirax 800mg sale zovirax 400mg cost zyloprim 100mg without prescription
can you take flagyl for uti
diuretic furosemide
xenical 120mg price buy diltiazem sale diltiazem 180mg uk
where to buy glycomet without a prescription order glycomet 500mg generic buy glycomet pills for sale
order priligy 60mg brand priligy 30mg misoprostol pills
buy aralen 250mg generic buy chloroquine 250mg pill buy chloroquine online
natural alternatives to metformin
claritin where to buy claritin online buy buy claritin for sale
cenforce 100mg without prescription cenforce 50mg canada cenforce cheap
clarinex 5mg for sale order clarinex pills oral desloratadine
cheap tadalafil for sale buy cialis 5mg
buy triamcinolone 10mg pill purchase triamcinolone pills order aristocort 10mg generic
hydroxychloroquine 200mg canada purchase plaquenil generic how to buy hydroxychloroquine
zithromax prescription
order lyrica pill lyrica 75mg without prescription purchase lyrica sale
order levitra 10mg online cheap buy cheap generic vardenafil
empire casino online blackjack free
semaglutide uk rybelsus uk buy semaglutide 14mg for sale
purchase doxycycline online monodox without prescription
sildenafil 100mg tablets generic viagra 50mg
oral lasix 40mg order lasix 40mg sale
clomiphene medication clomid 100mg tablet order clomid 100mg for sale
buy neurontin without prescription buy neurontin 800mg without prescription order neurontin 100mg pill
buy synthroid online buy synthroid 75mcg generic synthroid 100mcg without prescription
order omnacortil 5mg pill cost omnacortil 5mg omnacortil online buy
buy clavulanate online cheap buy clavulanate generic clavulanate where to buy
zithromax online buy azithromycin 500mg pills zithromax oral
order albuterol inhalator without prescription buy ventolin 2mg for sale order albuterol generic
cost amoxicillin 1000mg generic amoxil buy generic amoxicillin
buy generic isotretinoin 40mg cheap isotretinoin 10mg
purchase semaglutide buy semaglutide 14mg online cheap rybelsus 14 mg oral
prednisone 5mg pills order prednisone 40mg online cheap
rybelsus buy online generic rybelsus 14 mg order semaglutide 14mg generic
clomiphene order online buy clomiphene 50mg without prescription purchase clomid
levothroid cheap synthroid 150mcg price levothyroxine pills
order amoxiclav generic order generic augmentin 375mg
ventolin over the counter buy ventolin 4mg inhaler purchase albuterol inhaler
doxycycline 200mg us purchase doxycycline sale
order amoxicillin 250mg online order amoxicillin 500mg sale buy amoxicillin 1000mg online
buy deltasone 10mg without prescription
buy furosemide pills diuretic cheap lasix
order azipro 250mg generic azithromycin ca azipro 500mg brand
order gabapentin for sale buy gabapentin sale
oral azithromycin 250mg buy zithromax 500mg for sale buy zithromax 500mg sale
amoxicillin 1000mg for sale buy amoxil amoxicillin sale
top selling sleep aids generic provigil 100mg
isotretinoin 40mg for sale buy absorica pill
treat heartburn without antacids buy zidovudine medication
most recommended allergy medication buy albuterol online cheap best allergy medications over the counter
prescription medication for adult acne brand omnacortil 20mg treatment for acne in adults
acidity after eating anything retrovir ca
buy prednisone 5mg pill
virtual visit online physician belsomra order provigil sale
allergy pills on sale allergy medication without side effects generic allergy medication list