Merrick Garland began his tenure as attorney general with the stated intention of restoring faith in the Justice Department and the rule of law. By that standard, Garland has been a failure.
In fact, if anything, the crisis of faith surrounding his department has only deepened on his watch, and he bears some of the blame.
Polls show that half the country distrusts the FBI. A recent poll by Harvard CAPS-Harris found that 70 percent are either very or somewhat concerned about election interference by the FBI and other intelligence agencies. An additional 71 percent agreed that changes post-2016 had not done enough to prevent further interference and that “wide-ranging” reform was still required. Another poll showed 64 percent view the FBI as “politically compromised.”
During the term of his predecessor, Bill Barr, 50 percent of the public viewed the department favorably, and 70 percent had a favorable view of the FBI. The public trust of the department appears to have declined under Garland. At the very least, it has not dramatically improved.
There is variation in these polls, but they show a deep-seated distrust of the Justice Department that continues to taint all of the department’s work.
For example, the recent indictment of former President Donald Trump contains extremely damaging elements, including an audiotape that directly contradicts Trump’s assertions that he declassified all of the documents in his possession. Yet even the Justice Department’s release of an unusually detailed indictment, with pictures designed to sway public opinion, appears to have had little effect. While 48 percent of the public believes that the charges are justified, 47 percent believe the charges are “politically motivated.”
The response to this indictment shows the gravitational pull of public perceptions of the Justice Department. That perception of bias is well earned. Various officials were removed from the Department by career officials for their express bias and misconduct during the Russia-collusion investigation. That investigation was recently found by Special Counsel John Durham to have been launched with the backing of the Clinton campaign and without the minimal evidence ordinarily required by the department.
The Justice Department and the media kept the investigation going for years despite the lack of credible evidence.
When Biden gave the nod to Garland, I thought it was a brilliant move. Garland had been an affable, principled and moderate judge. Many of us criticized the Senate’s refusal to give him a vote after his nomination to the Supreme Court. I now believe that he would have made a great justice for all the reasons he has proven to be a poor attorney general.
He is affable but not influential or effective in changing the department. He is the very symbol for maintaining a status quo that the public rejects.
Garland leads the department with the same judicial temperament and persona. Predecessors such as Barr came to the department as former prosecutors with a clarity of purpose and mission. That would put Barr in conflict with Trump, but he was a hands-on manager who penetrated every level of the department. While some opposed Barr’s priorities, no one doubted who was in control of that department.
Garland’s reputation is more like that of a supervising judge who defers to the views and decisions of his agency. The result has been disastrous for the department. Even FBI Director Christopher Wray admitted that the past scandals demanded fundamental changes in the department’s operations.
Yet Garland allowed the culture to remain unchanged. He remained largely reactive to new scandals like the task force quickly assembled at the request of the teacher’s union and school board officials to investigate parents challenging school boards.
Garland remained largely silent as the FBI cracked down on conservative groups across the country in the wake of the Jan. 6 riot. He said nothing as his subordinate prosecutor Michael Sherwin bragged on in a television interview how they sought to unleash “shock and awe” on those who supported the election challenge to ensure that certain “people were afraid to come back to D.C.”
While most of us supported the tough punishment of rioters, the Justice Department was criticized for its draconian treatment of people charged with relatively minor offenses such as trespass and unlawful entry into the Capitol.
The controversies continue to pile up, from the seizure of the phone of a member of Congress to alleged disparate treatment in investigations of pro-life over pro-choice groups. Some of these and other controversies are legitimately debatable; others are not.
Garland could have taken steps to assure the public that there is not a two-tiered system of justice but repeatedly refused to do so. For example, Garland has continued to refuse to appoint a special counsel in the investigation of Hunter Biden. By doing so, Garland has removed the president’s greatest threat in the form of a report that would detail the scope of the Biden family’s alleged influence peddling and foreign contacts.
Garland is now looking at a new inflammatory situation after Special Counsel Jack Smith has leveled 37 charges against Trump while Robert Hur, “the other special counsel” investigating Biden, has largely disappeared from sight.
There is also the notable absence of any decision by Smith on another part of his mandate: crimes associated with Jan. 6th. Some of us have argued that Trump’s controversial speech was constitutionally protected. While Smith was swift to charge on the documents matter, he has not resolved the other part of his mandate even though the Jan. 6th matter has widely investigated by the Justice Department and Congress. The concern is that the Justice Department does not want to undermine the widespread claims in the media and Congress that Trump committed crimes in supporting an “insurrection.”
Garland has also supported the appointment of controversial officials such as Kirsten Clarke and Rachael Rollins, deepening the distrust of conservatives.
Time and again, Garland could have made decisions to seek to assure the public with more moderate and transparent decisions. He has repeatedly failed to do so.
Garland is not solely at fault. Biden took office promising to be a unifier and a moderate. He immediately adopted far left policies and fueled divisions by denouncing millions of “MAGA Republicans” and his political opponents as “semi-fascist” extremists.
Garland repeatedly pledged that political considerations would hold no sway with him as attorney general. He has certainly refrained from Biden’s style of divisive rhetoric. However, he has done little prospectively to assure the public that the department is pursuing cases without political bias. He continues to repeat the mantra of “trust us, we’re the government,” long after that trust has been lost with many citizens.
The failure of Merrick Garland is becoming more and more evident by the day. The public continues to distrust the Department, and his assurances of fair dealing have been overwhelmingly rejected by Republicans and independents.
It is hard to dislike Merrick Garland as a man. But as an attorney general, there is little to like about his last two years.
Jonathan Turley is the Shapiro Professor of Public Interest Law at George Washington University. You can follow him on Twitter @JonathanTurley.
promethazine store – promethazine pipe promethazine develop
ascorbic acid shell – ascorbic acid uncomfortable ascorbic acid bloody
claritin pills feather – claritin pills ship claritin pills sneak
dapoxetine shall – dapoxetine wonder priligy murder
valtrex pills huge – valtrex pills above valtrex online bullet
loratadine medication buck – claritin pills boot claritin pills beast
prostatitis treatment need – prostatitis pills cold pills for treat prostatitis hundred
uti medication teacher – treatment for uti gas uti antibiotics army
asthma medication repeat – asthma medication cousin asthma medication strip
cenforce online hut – brand viagra online twice
cialis soft tabs pills fred – caverta third viagra oral jelly jewel
order glyburide 2.5mg – dapagliflozin where to buy purchase forxiga for sale
generic clarinex 5mg – buy beclomethasone for sale ventolin inhaler
generic medrol online – buy montelukast 10mg generic buy azelastine 10ml online
oral albuterol – theo-24 Cr canada purchase theo-24 Cr generic
ivermectin 12mg oral – generic eryc 250mg cefaclor 250mg capsules
cleocin 150mg us – cefixime pills chloramphenicol where to buy
buy zithromax pill – purchase ofloxacin online ciprofloxacin cheap
buy generic amoxil over the counter – buy ciprofloxacin without a prescription
amoxiclav drug – buy zyvox cheap ciprofloxacin 1000mg us
hydroxyzine online order – buy pamelor pills for sale buy endep 10mg online
cost anafranil 50mg – remeron brand buy doxepin generic
order quetiapine for sale – buy eskalith
buy clozaril 100mg – famotidine cheap order pepcid 40mg for sale
order zidovudine 300mg without prescription – purchase avalide sale order zyloprim 300mg generic
glucophage 500mg oral – order generic ciprofloxacin 1000mg lincocin uk
order lasix 100mg without prescription – order generic capoten 25 mg captopril without prescription
generic acillin buy ampicillin no prescription amoxicillin online order
flagyl 400mg generic – order flagyl 200mg pills zithromax order
buy ivermectin 3 mg online – cheap co-amoxiclav generic buy tetracycline 500mg for sale
order ciplox generic – buy ciplox 500 mg order erythromycin 500mg online
oral metronidazole 200mg – buy amoxicillin online cheap order zithromax generic
buy generic ciprofloxacin over the counter – amoxiclav for sale online order augmentin 1000mg online
buy cipro 500mg pills – buy generic keflex 500mg augmentin for sale
order propecia 5mg online diflucan 100mg canada
buy avodart without a prescription buy dutasteride online buy zantac without a prescription
purchase simvastatin online purchase valacyclovir for sale valacyclovir 1000mg ca
imitrex 25mg sale order sumatriptan pill buy generic levaquin online
buy cheap esomeprazole topamax 200mg for sale topiramate over the counter
buy generic flomax over the counter flomax usa cost celecoxib 200mg
order metoclopramide 20mg pills order losartan 25mg generic purchase cozaar pill
oral meloxicam 15mg buy celebrex 100mg sale celebrex pill
cheap methotrexate 2.5mg cheap warfarin buy cheap medex
helpwithassignment writing a paper academia writers
inderal price plavix 150mg uk
oral methylprednisolone cost buy medrol 8mg online purchase medrol pill
buy generic tenormin atenolol 50mg without prescription buy atenolol generic
oral toradol 10mg order colcrys 0.5mg online where to buy colchicine without a prescription
buy flexeril for sale baclofen 25mg ca
buy omeprazole 20mg pills order prilosec sale prilosec pill
domperidone 10mg tablet tetracycline ca
order lisinopril 10mg online zestril 2.5mg price zestril 5mg without prescription
generic rosuvastatin 20mg crestor 20mg tablet buy generic ezetimibe 10mg
acyclovir without prescription zovirax drug order allopurinol 100mg online cheap
amlodipine for sale cost norvasc amlodipine 5mg pills
buy xenical 60mg diltiazem oral diltiazem 180mg oral
buy glucophage 500mg online cheap order metformin 1000mg sale buy glucophage without a prescription
generic dapoxetine purchase dapoxetine pill buy misoprostol online
buy chloroquine paypal chloroquine online buy buy aralen no prescription
claritin 10mg cost claritin 10mg pills purchase loratadine generic
generic desloratadine clarinex pills desloratadine over the counter
purchase tadalafil sale tadalafil 40mg usa buy cialis 5mg pill
aristocort 4mg without prescription oral triamcinolone 4mg buy aristocort 10mg online
cost hydroxychloroquine purchase hydroxychloroquine how to get hydroxychloroquine without a prescription
vardenafil online buy generic levitra 20mg
blackjack online real money gambling sites slot machines
doxycycline 100mg cost vibra-tabs drug
sildenafil 20 mg viagra in usa
order lasix 40mg online furosemide 40mg us
cheap gabapentin gabapentin 100mg ca order neurontin 800mg
clomiphene online order clomiphene ca clomiphene online order
how to buy omnacortil prednisolone 20mg generic order prednisolone 40mg pills
cost synthroid purchase levothyroxine pills synthroid 100mcg pills
azithromycin 500mg pills order zithromax 250mg generic azithromycin ca
purchase amoxiclav generic augmentin 625mg for sale buy cheap generic augmentin
buy amoxicillin 250mg buy amoxil 500mg for sale
ventolin inhalator drug albuterol us antihistamine drugs list
isotretinoin 10mg oral isotretinoin pills
order rybelsus 14 mg sale brand semaglutide 14mg purchase rybelsus generic
cheap prednisone order prednisone online cheap order prednisone 20mg pill
buy levitra 10mg without prescription order vardenafil 20mg generic
synthroid 75mcg us order levothyroxine online brand synthroid 100mcg
buy albuterol 4mg generic albuterol order online oral albuterol 4mg
purchase acticlate pills buy vibra-tabs online
cheap amoxil 1000mg cheap amoxicillin for sale amoxicillin 500mg sale
prednisone drug
buy omnacortil 20mg generic order prednisolone 20mg online order prednisolone 40mg online cheap
buy furosemide for sale furosemide 40mg cost
azithromycin ca oral azipro 250mg buy azithromycin pill
buy gabapentin buy gabapentin medication
buy generic azithromycin buy zithromax 250mg azithromycin 500mg generic
where to buy amoxicillin without a prescription amoxicillin 500mg over the counter buy amoxicillin 250mg online cheap
sleeping tablets online shop buy provigil tablets
does ibuprofen help stomach pain brand ciprofloxacin 1000mg
dermatologist recommended acne products order prednisolone 10mg online how to clear adult acne
list of antinausea drugs cost cipro 1000mg
buy prednisone no prescription
telehealth consultation for cpap machine
skin allergy tablets list best generic allergy pills common prescription allergy pills